So close yet oh so far away once again, eh, English language? I think you enjoy keeping us on our toes, but we’re ready for you. We know “unorganized” and “disorganized” are near-synonyms but not exact matches, but what’s the difference between these two words? And what do their different pre-fixes accomplish? What can history tell us?
Oh, yeah, let’s go there.
Will this conversation be messy? With these two adjectives, it’s entirely possible, but we’ll make it through.
Perhaps the most fascinating way to start the “unorganized” vs. “disorganized” conversation is to begin with the difference between “unease” and “disease,” which shows off these same two negative prefixes in action. There’s a clear difference, and it traces back to the subtleties of “un-” vs. “dis-.”
(This is where I want to insert the Jeopardy! music while you see if you can detect it.)
Got it? Maybe? No?
Here it is:
Frequently, while both “un” and “dis” are used as negative prefixes, “dis” implies not only the negative but a reversal. Thus, one who was once at ease might have a “disease.” A room that once organized might now be “disorganized.” If Alice’s White Rabbit was once there, it might “disappear.” It’s not just the opposite but a reversal.
Thus, the difference between “unorganized” vs. “disorganized” is that:
- “Unorganized” means to be in disarray, a mess, uncategorized, or otherwise unordered.
- “Disorganized” implies that something or someone was once organized and that the organization is gone. A disorganized person might have taken things that were organized and allowed them to fall into confusion.
“Un-” is the older prefix, having come from Old English, and “dis-” came to the English language in a wave of Latin and French influence upon Middle English (also see the prefix “de-” in the same era). Specifically, “Unorganized” has been an English word in its present form since 1653 , and “disorganized” has been in use since 1801.
Do these “un-” vs. “dis-” reversal distinctions always ring true? Of course not. As endlessly noted, the English language is bad at following its own rules. Look at the word “discomfort.” If you experience “discomfort,” you are “uncomfortable.” Sigh. (Yes, this is me sighing at the discomfort the English language creates when folks simply want to learn the cut-and-dried rules, though if you want to hash out the reversals in “comfort” vs. “discomfort” and the simple negativity of “comfortable” vs. “uncomfortable,” I’m more than willing to have that conversation.)
Those who have ever been to one of my Grammartopia events might know that questioning an audience member about whether they are “disinterested” or “uninterested” in learning the subtleties of grammar is one of my favorite side conversations.
Wait, is it possible to have a favorite grammar conversation? Perhaps not. And that’s not a matter or being disorganized or unorganized. It’s just a matter of the endless curiosities provoked by proper language use. Who’s with me?
Happy writing, folks!
Sign up for my monthly writing and editing tips and trivia email newsletter for more like this.